Home › Book Two: Bra Discipline
Chapter 3: Getting the Size Right
A bra that fits is comfortable enough to wear all day. A bra that doesn't is miserable - and it'll sink the whole project. Spend the time to get this right.
Part 1: Measuring
How to measure him
You need a soft measuring tape and two numbers.
Band: Measure snugly around his ribcage, right under his pecs, keeping the tape level. Round to the nearest inch. For most men, this number is the band size, or very close - if it's odd, try both the size above and below.
Bust: Measure loosely around the fullest part of his chest. The difference between bust and band gives you a rough cup size - but for most guys that difference is small, which is why cup sizing for men is more about the style than the letter.
Tips for an accurate measurement
Use a soft fabric tape, not a metal one.
Measure on bare skin, or over a thin t-shirt at most.
Have him stand naturally - not puffing out his chest or sucking in his stomach.
Measure at the end of a normal breath out.
Check the tape is level all the way around, using a mirror.
Take each measurement twice.
A home fitting, step by step
Have him stand straight, arms relaxed, wearing nothing on top.
Measure his underbust: snug, level, just below his chest. Breathe out first.
Measure his bust: loosely around the fullest part.
Note both numbers, then calculate a starting size (see "A worked example" above).
Order two or three sizes around that starting point, in a forgiving style.
Try each on with the checklist above. Note what fits, what pinches, what gapes.
Keep the best; return or donate the rest. Record his size and the brand.
A worked example
Say his underbust (band) measures 39 inches and his chest at the fullest point (bust) measures 40 inches.
Band: 39 is odd, so try both a 38 and a 40. Most men prefer the larger for comfort at first.
Cup: bust minus band. 40 - 38 = 2 (a B) or 40 - 40 = 0 (an AA). For a flat chest, either an unlined 38A/B or 40AA/A is a sensible starting point.
Sports bra: check the brand's chart for a 39-40 inch chest - often a large or XL.
A second example
Ray measures 41 inches around his ribs, just under the chest, and 42 inches around the fullest part of his chest. Rounding the band up to the nearest even number gives 42. The difference between the chest and band measurements is about one inch, which suggests an A cup - but on a flat male chest, cups rarely fill, so a 42AA or 42A in a soft, unlined style is the place to start. If the band feels too tight on the loosest hook, try a 44A or add an extender.
Rough starting points
These are only rough guides - always measure and check each brand:
Slim build (men's shirt S): band 34-36, cup AA-A, sports S-M.
Average build (men's shirt M): band 36-38, cup A-B, sports M-L.
Larger build (men's shirt L): band 40-42, cup A-C, sports L-XL.
Big and tall (men's shirt XL+): band 42-46, look at extended sizes and plus-size brands.
Sizing different body types
Broad, muscular chest: larger band; soft or stretch cups that conform to the chest muscles.
Some natural chest tissue: measure carefully - he may genuinely fill an A or B cup. Soft-cup and t-shirt bras work well.
Larger belly: measure the underbust carefully; the band sits above the belly. A longer band or band extender helps.
Slim build: smaller bands (32-36); AA or A cups; bralettes are ideal.
Very tall: longer straps or convertible straps; check the strap length on the size chart.
The slim build
Slim men often fall into band sizes 32 to 36, which are easy to find. The challenge is the cups: very small, triangle or bralette styles fit best.
The athletic build
Broad shoulders and a defined chest can actually fill a small cup. Racerback and sports styles fit beautifully; underwires often press against the pectorals.
The heavier build
Larger bands, sometimes with more natural fullness in the cup. Full-coverage and longline styles are comfortable, and wider straps spread the load.
When he measures himself
If he has to measure himself, have him stand in front of a mirror to keep the tape level, breathe out normally before taking the band measurement, and measure twice. Better still, measure him yourself - it's quicker, more accurate, and part of the ritual.
Very large and very small men
For very large men, look at plus-size and extended-size ranges, which go up to band 50 and beyond, and consider band extenders. For very slim men, look at smaller bands (30-34) in petite or junior ranges, and soft bralettes that won't gape.
Part 2: Fit
Band is everything
On a man, the band does almost all of the work. It should sit level all the way around, snug but not tight - you should be able to slide two fingers under it. If it rides up in back, it's too big. If it leaves deep marks or makes breathing uncomfortable, it's too small. Start on the loosest hook; bands stretch over time and he can tighten as it does.
Testing the band
The two-finger test: two fingers slide under the band at the back, snugly. More than that is too loose.
The arms-up test: he raises both arms above his head. If the band rides up, it's too loose.
The deep-breath test: he breathes in fully. If it feels restrictive, it's too tight.
The level test: from the side, the band should be horizontal, not higher at the back.
Cups for a flat chest
If he has little or no breast tissue, regular molded cups will either cave in or stick out. Better options:
Bralettes and soft-cup styles, which lie flat.
AA or A cups in an unlined style.
Bras designed for men - a niche but growing category.
Sports and compression bras, which are sized S/M/L and have no cups to fill.
Padding or forms, if you want cups that are filled out - more on that in Chapter 9.
Gaping, wrinkling and floating
On a flat chest, molded cups often stand away from the body, leaving a gap at the top; unlined cups may wrinkle. Neither is a problem at home, but both can show under a fitted shirt. Soft-cup, triangle and compression styles lie flat. If you want structured cups to sit properly, light padding or inserts will fill the space.
Straps
Men's shoulders are usually broader and squarer, so straps may need to be let out more than you'd expect. Wide, padded straps are more comfortable for long wear. Convertible straps that can be crossed in back help stop slipping.
Strap placement on broad shoulders
Many bras set straps for narrower shoulders, so on a man they sit near the edge and slip. Look for straps set closer to the center, racerback or convertible styles, or "J-hooks" that pull the straps together at the back. Tightening straps won't solve a placement problem and only shifts the weight from the band to his shoulders.
Band extenders
A small hook-and-eye extender is a cheap, life-changing accessory. It lets you buy cute styles that run small in the band and still have him comfortable. Keep a few in the drawer.
Extenders come in one-, two- and three-hook widths and in several colors; buy one that matches the hook count on his bra. They're also handy in the first week, when a new band feels tighter than it will after a few wears.
Sister sizes
A bra's cup volume depends on the band. Go down a band size and up a cup (40A to 38B) and the cups hold about the same volume on a snugger band. Go up a band and down a cup (38B to 40A) for a looser band with similar cups. For a man, sister sizes are most useful when a band feels too tight or too loose but the cups are fine.
The try-on checklist
Fasten on the loosest hook.
Adjust straps so they're snug but not pulling.
Check the band is level - look in a mirror from the side.
Two fingers fit under the band; no more.
Raise both arms over his head. The band should stay put.
Take a deep breath. Comfortable? Good.
Put a t-shirt on top. Look front, back and side.
Sit down, lean forward, twist. Anything dig in?
The movement test
Once he's in the bra, have him move as he would during a normal day: sit at a desk, reach for a high shelf, bend to tie a shoe, twist to look behind him, and walk briskly across the room. If the band rides up, the straps slip, or anything digs in, try another size or style.
Part 3: Buying
Why he needs bras of his own
It's tempting to start him off in one of yours. For a first evening, that's fine. But for anything more, he needs his own - for several reasons.
Fit. Your bras are built for your band and cup. On him, the band will almost certainly be too small and the cups the wrong shape. An ill-fitting bra is uncomfortable, easy to spot under clothes, and puts him off the whole idea.
Your bras. He'll stretch them, and you'll want them back.
Hygiene. Bras are worn against the skin all day. Each of you should have your own.
Meaning. A bra bought for him, in his size, chosen by you, is a far stronger symbol than a borrowed one. It says: this is yours now. This is part of who you are.
The symbolism of his own size
When you measure him, write his size down, and buy bras specifically for him, you're saying something important: this isn't a joke or a costume. These are his bras, made to fit his body. That turns a game into a practice.
Sizing systems
US and UK band sizes are in inches and usually match; cup letters match up to DD and then diverge. European bands are in centimeters, roughly the US band multiplied by 2.54 and rounded to the nearest 5 (a US 38 is about a European 85). French and Spanish sizes add 15 to the European number. When ordering from abroad, always use the brand's own conversion chart.
Ordering online
Read the size chart, not just the size label.
Read reviews for "runs small," "runs large" and comments from larger customers.
Order two sizes when unsure, and return one.
Check the return policy - unworn bras can usually be returned.
Keep a note of what fit and what didn't.
Professional fittings
Department stores and lingerie boutiques offer free bra fittings. Many fitters are entirely unfazed by men - they've seen everything. If he's brave enough (and you're both comfortable with it), a professional fitting can be an eye-opening experience and an excellent way to find his true size. Go together, and say simply: "We're shopping for him."
Common sizing mistakes
Band too big, because it feels comfortable in the store. It will ride up and slip within an hour.
Cups too big, because he's a big man. On a flat chest, large cups wrinkle and show.
Straps doing all the work, digging into his shoulders.
Ignoring the brand. Sizes vary considerably; always check each chart.
Never re-measuring. Weight changes, and so does his size.
Quality and price
Inexpensive bras are fine for trying sizes and styles. For everyday wear, a mid-range bra usually lasts longer, keeps its shape and is more comfortable - worth it for something he'll wear for hours every day. Save premium bras for special occasions and gifts.
Buying her size
Your bras won't fit him, even if you're a similar size around. Men's ribcages and shoulders are shaped differently, so always measure him.
Choosing a band that's too big
The most common error of all. A loose band rides up, the straps take the weight and dig in, and he spends the day tugging. Snug is right.
Not re-measuring
Weight changes, workouts and even posture alter his size. Check every few months.
His size record
Keep a small card or note with his details, updated every few months:
Date measured: ______
Underbust: ______ Bust: ______
Usual size: ______ Sports bra: ______
Brands that fit: ______
Brands that don't: ______
Notes: ______
It saves time and guesswork every time you shop.
What professional fitters say
"Most people wear a band that's too loose."
"Fit the band first, then worry about the cups."
"Try at least three sizes."
"Raise your arms - if the band moves, it's too big."
"Your size changes with your weight and with the brand."
Choosing the wrong size on purpose
Everything above is about getting the fit right, and for everyday wear that is what you want. But fit is also one of the simplest tools you have. A bra that fits perfectly is easy to forget; a bra that is deliberately a little wrong is impossible to forget. Choosing the wrong size on purpose costs nothing, needs no special bra, and can be done with bras he already owns. (For how this fits into a system of consequences, see Chapter 8.)
Why cup size barely matters on a man
Because he has no breasts, the cups have nothing to hold. The band and straps do all the work, so for a man the "size" that matters is almost entirely the band. That frees you to choose the cups for effect rather than fit:
Small cups (AA, A) lie close to his chest and disappear under a shirt - the discreet choice.
Large cups (C and up) stand away from his chest, wrinkle and fold. Under a loose sweater no one will notice, but he will: he can feel the empty cups shift every time he moves, and he sees them every time he looks down. At home, they're an unmistakable reminder of what he's wearing.
Padded or molded large cups keep their shape even empty, giving him a bust-like outline - a firmer reminder, and one for home or under heavy layers only.
The tight band
A band one size smaller than he needs - or his usual bra fastened on the tightest hook - turns a comfortable bra into a constant presence. He feels it with every breath, every time he sits down, every time he reaches for something. He sits up straighter because slouching makes it dig in. It's a quiet, physical reminder that lasts all day, and nobody else can see it.
Go down one band size (from a 40 to a 38) and fasten on the loosest hook to start. Two sizes down is too far for most men.
Or use his usual size on the tightest hook, which is gentler and can be adjusted during the day.
Change the finger test: where a correct band takes two fingers underneath, a punishment band takes one.
Pair it with a longline for the firmest version: a deep band, a size too small, is felt from chest to waist.
A tight band shows more. A band that fits lies flat against his back; a band that's too tight digs in. The skin above and below it bulges slightly, so under a fitted shirt the band shows as a clear horizontal line across his back - sometimes with a visible ridge where the hooks sit. Tight straps dig into his shoulders the same way and leave defined grooves that can show through a thin shirt. This is part of what makes a tight band such a strong punishment: he knows the outline is more visible, so he's more careful all day about how he sits, stands and reaches. It's also something to manage. If he's wearing a tight band to work, a crew-neck undershirt and a looser, darker or patterned shirt - or a sweater or jacket - keep the lines hidden. At home, a thin, fitted white T-shirt over a tight band does the opposite: it shows every line, which is exactly the point.
The loose band, an extender, and slipping straps
The opposite approach works just as well. A band that is too big - made bigger still with a band extender - rides up his back toward his shoulder blades. As it rises, it pulls the straps outward and loosens them, and on a man's straight, broad shoulders they start to slide off. He spends the day pushing his straps back up: through his shirt, under his jacket, in the restroom mirror. Each time, he's reminded of what he did and who chose the bra.
Choose a band one or two sizes too large, or his correct band with a two- or three-hook extender.
Choose a style with wide-set straps - a balconette, a demi-cup or a plunge. Straps that sit near the edge of the shoulder slip much more easily than those set close to the neck.
Leave the straps loose and forbid racerbacks, strap clips and crossing the straps.
Add a rule: straps may only be fixed discreetly, never by reaching inside his shirt in public. If a strap ends up around his elbow, he tells you.
Slipping straps work best at home, on errands and at weekends. At work, constantly adjusting a strap draws attention; if you use it on a workday, make sure he wears a jacket or sweater. For an even stronger version of the same idea, see the strapless bra in Chapter 5.
Other deliberate misfits
The wrong hook: a bra he usually wears on the middle hook, fastened on the tightest - or the loosest - for the day.
Mismatched straps: one strap tight, one loose, so the bra sits crooked and he keeps noticing it.
An underwire a size too small: the wires press into his ribs at the sides. For an evening only.
A sports bra a size down: a firm, all-over squeeze. Never for the gym, where he needs to breathe freely.
Using a wrong size well
Tell him why he's wearing it. "You'll wear the 36 today, on the tightest hook, and every time you feel it I want you to think about last night." Keep it proportionate: a tight band is a punishment for hours or a single day, not a week. And end it properly. When the day is over, unhook it yourself and hand him his correctly fitted bra - the relief is part of the lesson, and it reminds him that the right fit is something he has because you allow it.
Safety limits
He must always be able to take a full, deep breath. If he can't, it's too tight. Loosen it immediately.
Stop at once for dizziness, shortness of breath, numbness or tingling in his arms, sharp pain, or skin that is broken or blistering.
No tight bands for the gym, physical work, long drives, sleep or hot days.
Check the marks when it comes off. Red lines that fade within an hour are normal; deep grooves or bruising mean it was too tight or worn too long.
Not with existing conditions: skip tight bands entirely if he has asthma, a heart or lung condition, rib injuries or back problems.
Part 4: Questions
Questions and answers
What size are most men?
Band sizes from about 36 to 44, with A to B cups (or AA for very flat chests). But every man is different - measure.
Do men need different bras than women?
Not necessarily. Many women's bras fit men well, especially soft-cup, wireless and sports styles. A few brands make bras cut specifically for men.
How many bras does he need?
For daily wear, five to seven, so each can rest between wears. Fewer if he wears one only on weekends.
Should I measure him again later?
Every six months or so, and whenever his weight changes noticeably.
Should the bra be tight?
Snug, not tight. The band should stay put without digging in; he should be able to breathe and move freely.
Can he wear a bra that's slightly too big?
For a short time, but it will ride up and slip, and it's more likely to show. Correct fit is worth the effort.
Why does the same size fit differently in different brands?
Each brand uses its own patterns and sizing. Always check the chart, and keep notes on what works.
Can I measure him over a T-shirt?
A thin T-shirt is fine; anything thicker will add an inch or more. For the most accurate result, measure over bare skin.
What if he's between band sizes?
Try both. Most men are more comfortable in the larger band on its tightest hook than the smaller band on its loosest, because the band will stretch a little with wear.
Should I buy several of the same bra once I find one that fits?
Yes. A style that fits well is worth buying in two or three colors - skin tone for work, plus something prettier for home.