Lace & Order

Home › Book Three: Lingerie Punishments

Chapter 5: Let Him Choose

One of the most effective ways to punish a man is to make him choose his own punishment - and then to tell him that he has chosen wrongly. Picking a punishment forces him to think honestly about what he did, what it deserves and what he is most reluctant to wear. Being sent back to try again teaches humility far better than any lecture.

Keep guessing until it's right

This is the simplest version. Decide privately what his punishment will be - write it on a slip of paper and fold it away. Then tell him he has earned a punishment and must suggest one himself. If he picks anything other than what you wrote, the answer is simply "Wrong. Try again." Each wrong guess has a cost - add a minute of corner time, one more line to write, or one more item to his outfit - so that by the time he finally names the right one, he has already been punished a little for each miss.

Some useful refinements:

  • Warmer or colder. If he is floundering, give him clues: "colder" when he suggests something too mild, "warmer" as he approaches the truth. Men tend to guess low at first, hoping to get away lightly. They learn quickly.

  • He must ask properly. Each guess must be phrased as a request: "Please may I wear my pink panties to work tomorrow?" Hearing himself ask for each possibility, out loud, is half the lesson.

  • Wrong guesses are kept. For a serious offense, every wrong answer that is milder than the real one is added to the punishment too. He will start guessing high very fast.

  • Guess too high and you keep it. Guessing high is no escape either. If he names something harsher than what you wrote down, he has volunteered for it - so he keeps that punishment as well, on top of the right one when he finally finds it. Now every guess is a gamble: too low costs him a penalty, too high costs him the whole punishment he suggested. The only safe answer is the honest one - what does he really think he deserves? Use this rule alongside the others or on its own, but tell him before the guessing begins, so he knows the stakes.

  • Reveal the slip. When he finally gets it right, unfold the paper and show him it was there all along. Knowing it was decided before he ever opened his mouth is deliciously humbling.

You write it downfolded, in secretHe guessesasking politely, out loudToo lowsmall penalty addedRight!reveal the slipToo highhe keeps that one tooguess againguess againPunishment begins
The guessing game, with both rules.

The menu

Write out three or four punishments of roughly equal weight and let him choose from the menu. What he chooses tells you a great deal - and you are entirely free to say, "Interesting. I'll remember that's the one you were most afraid of," and save it for next time.

Two envelopes

Seal two punishments in two envelopes. One is mild; one is not. He must pick one without opening either. Before he opens it, offer him a swap - but only in exchange for an extra task. Many men cannot resist, and many regret it.

Bidding

Name the offense and ask him to propose a fair punishment. If his proposal is too lenient, say "higher" and wait. He keeps raising his own bid - more hours, frillier garments, more lines - until you are satisfied. The punishment he ends up with is one he suggested himself, which makes it very hard for him to complain about it later.

He chooses the garment, you choose the rest

A gentler option for mild offenses: he selects which punishment garment to wear, but you choose when, where and for how long. Or the reverse - you choose the garment, and he must decide how long he deserves to wear it. If his answer is too short, you know what to say.

Keep it fair

The guessing game must always have a right answer, and that answer must be something that fits your agreed limits. Never use it to trap him into something he would refuse, and keep the number of wrong guesses within reason. Ten minutes of guessing is a punishment; an hour is just frustrating for you both. If you use the too-high rule, agree a cap - say, no more than one extra punishment kept - so that a nervous run of high guesses cannot snowball into something neither of you wanted.

Nothing to show. Press Esc or tap to return.